In this blog post, I examined the bizarre and contradictory characters in ‘The Hunchback of Notre Dame’, the perspective on humanity embedded within them, and the life and literary world of Victor Hugo, while reflecting on the sense of unease and comfort conveyed by this novel.
- A Novel Without an Admired Protagonist
- A Grotesque World Depicting Monstrous Human Beings
- Miserable Humans and the Potential for Greatness
- Beauty Found in an Ugly Life
- Should I read 'Les Misérables' first?
- A Work More Familiar as 'The Hunchback of Notre Dame'
- Victor Hugo’s Childhood and Literary Development
- The Shift in Hugo’s Literary World Following His Daughter’s Death
- Political Life and Later Years
- Hugo’s Life Until the Very End
A Novel Without an Admired Protagonist
After reading ‘The Hunchback of Notre Dame’, the first thing that comes to mind is Quasimodo’s tragic love. One might feel sympathy for his love, or even perceive a sense of sublimity in that tragic romance. Yet, while reading the work, one also feels a lingering unease that is hard to shake off. This is because the kind of admirable or heroic protagonist we generally expect to find in a novel is nowhere to be seen in this work.
If you think about it carefully, not a single character in ‘The Hunchback of Notre Dame’ can be described as “normal” or “admirable.” Far from being admirable, the protagonists feel almost like monsters. It’s only natural to feel aversion toward Archdeacon Frollo, a clergyman consumed by lust. Even Quasimodo, who evokes our sympathy, appears more like a monster than a human being when judged solely by his appearance. He is a character whose appearance inevitably inspires revulsion in anyone who sees him.
The other characters are not much different. Phœbus, whom the chaste Esmeralda loved so passionately, is a womanizer and a selfish man unworthy of her love. Grangouard, the poet and playwright, merely observes the events unfolding around him from a distance rather than actively engaging with them. He is, in the end, little more than a bystander who merely watches the events unfold. It is difficult to say that any of them is a commendable character who captures our hearts.
Of course, Esmeralda seems to be the exception. As Claude Frollo says in the story, she is an angelic, kind, and compassionate woman. However, if asked whether we would want to be like her, it would be hard to answer “yes” without hesitation. She is an unfortunate woman and a Gypsy dancer. She finds herself in an environment that makes her prone to corruption, and above all, she displays a foolish devotion, loving the womanizing Phaebus—who does not love her—until the very moment of her death. While she is clearly a character who evokes our sympathy, it is difficult to say she is an admirable figure whom everyone would envy. She is beautiful both in appearance and in heart, but it is precisely because of that beauty that she is an even more pitiable character.
A Grotesque World Depicting Monstrous Human Beings
‘The Hunchback of Notre Dame’ features many characters who, based on their professions alone, could potentially be admirable figures. These include the President of the Paris Court, the Archbishop of Notre Dame, judges, and prosecutors—people who could be considered leaders of society. Yet they are all portrayed in a ridiculous light. In fact, one might even find more human virtues among the beggars and vagrants.
So why did Victor Hugo, at such a young age, write a novel featuring such monstrous and utterly undesirable characters? The reason is that ‘The Hunchback of Notre-Dame’ is a work that embodies the “theory of the grotesque” that Hugo championed while spearheading the French Romantic movement.
“Grotesque” is a French word meaning “bizarre” or “ridiculous.” A key tenet of the theory of the grotesque is that this world cannot consist solely of admirable human beings. No matter how admirable a person may be, there is always a side within them that is the opposite of that. A good literary work must reveal both of these sides simultaneously.
From the perspective of the grotesque, Classicism—which limited itself to portraying only the ideal human form—effectively showed only half of humanity. Humans are not merely good and beautiful beings; within them lie ugly, bizarre, and ridiculous aspects as well. I believe this is precisely why ‘The Hunchback of Notre Dame’ feels so unsettling. The work does not show us only the aspects of humanity we wish to see. Rather, it confronts us head-on with the aspects of humanity we would prefer to ignore.
Miserable Humans and the Potential for Greatness
Reading ‘The Hunchback of Notre Dame’ leads one to ponder what it truly means to be human. The 17th-century French philosopher Pascal, famous for the phrase “Man is a thinking reed,” described humans as wretched beings. Yet at the same time, he also said that humans are great beings. How can one be both wretched and great? What does that even mean? When and how can a wretched human being become great?
Pascal’s explanation is surprisingly simple. It is only when humans come to realize that they are wretched beings that they gain the potential to become great. The moment they realize their wretchedness, they can look toward something greater that transcends that wretchedness and strive for it. Conversely, if they deny the fact that they are wretched or remain unaware of it while wallowing in arrogance, they are doomed to remain trapped in their wretchedness forever.
When viewed this way, the grotesque characters in ‘The Hunchback of Notre Dame’ are, in the end, reflections of ourselves. Within each of us lies another self—one that is bizarre and ridiculous. Perhaps it is simply human nature to confess, as the lyrics of the song “Thorn Bush” put it, “There are so many of me inside me.”
That confession is painful, because it requires acknowledging that the self I imagined might differ from my true self. Yet, as Pascal said, the moment we make that very confession, a wider world opens up. While works that reassure our anxious selves and comfort our suffering selves are good, I believe works that shake us to our core by helping us discover the other self within us are equally good. ‘The Hunchback of Notre Dame’ is precisely such a work.
Beauty Found in an Ugly Life
That said, the other self within me does not merely shake me up. Hidden within me is also the potential to transform our utterly ugly lives into something beautiful. In ‘The Hunchback of Notre Dame’, Quasimodo’s incredibly pure and innocent love for Esmeralda demonstrates precisely that potential.
Quasimodo’s appearance is so hideous that it would inspire revulsion in anyone. Yet his love is purer and more genuine than anyone else’s. That love offers solace to our vulgar and miserable lives. As I read this work, I, too, came to realize that I can find comfort in the moment I feel, “Perhaps there is a pure soul within me as well.”
That is why ‘The Hunchback of Notre Dame’ cannot be read merely as a tragic love story. This work helps us discover the ugly and grotesque aspects within ourselves while simultaneously revealing the potential for beauty hidden within them. The turmoil and comfort we feel while reading the work may seem like different emotions, but perhaps they both stem from a single perspective on humanity.
Should I read ‘Les Misérables’ first?
‘The Hunchback of Notre Dame’ is one of Victor Hugo’s early works. His other masterpiece, ‘Les Misérables’, was a work he began writing at age 43 and published at age 60; so, logically speaking, it seems like the natural order would be to read ‘The Hunchback of Notre Dame’ first. However, if we consider these two works together, I would actually recommend reading ‘Les Misérables’ first.
The reason is simple: I believe reading ‘Les Misérables’ first, followed by ‘The Hunchback of Notre Dame’, is the best way to enjoy both works. After reading ‘Les Misérables’, which broadly encompasses Hugo’s various ideas and literary world, it becomes much easier to understand ‘The Hunchback of Notre Dame’. ‘Les Misérables’ can also answer many of the questions that arise while reading ‘The Hunchback of Notre Dame’. After all, it’s often easier to grasp the meaning of the small details when viewed within a larger context.
Of course, it’s also meaningful to examine how the literary tendencies evident in Hugo’s early works evolved and deepened over time. However, such an analysis falls more within the realm of specialized scholarship. For literature enthusiasts and readers like us, the very act of reading a work and reflecting on what we feel and think while doing so may be more important.
A Work More Familiar as ‘The Hunchback of Notre Dame’
As everyone knows, ‘The Hunchback of Notre Dame’ is also more widely known under the title ‘The Hunchback of Notre Dame’. This is because countless films and musicals have used that title. So, if you happen to think of ‘The Hunchback of Notre-Dame’ and ‘The Hunchback of Notre-Dame’ as two different works, it’s important to remember that they refer to the same work.
Victor Hugo’s Childhood and Literary Development
Victor Marie Hugo was born on February 26, 1802, in Besançon. Following his father, a general under Napoleon, he grew up moving from city to city across France, Italy, and Spain from a young age. Later, in accordance with his father’s wishes, he entered university to study law, but Victor became absorbed in writing poetry and nurtured his dream of becoming a writer.
One of the people who influenced him most was the French Romantic poet Chateaubriand. Hugo, who had admired him since childhood, even wrote in his diary at the age of fourteen, “I want to be like Chateaubriand.”
Hugo married his childhood friend, Adèle Foucher, in 1822. That same year, he published his first collection of poems, ‘Odes’, which brought him widespread attention. He subsequently published a series of plays and poetry collections, rising to prominence as the literary world’s darling before he even turned thirty and becoming a leading figure of French Romanticism. In 1831, he solidified his reputation as a novelist with the publication of ‘The Hunchback of Notre-Dame’.
The Shift in Hugo’s Literary World Following His Daughter’s Death
If one were to name the event that had the greatest impact on Hugo’s life, one could not overlook the death of his daughter, Léopoldine, in the fall of 1843. Léopoldine, the daughter he cherished most, drowned in the Seine River along with her husband in an accident. Around the time of this tragedy, the tone of Hugo’s work began to change. The afterlife and the nature of the soul became his primary concerns.
In 1845, two years after his daughter’s death, Hugo began writing ‘Les Misérables’. He subsequently entered politics and continued his prolific creative work. He also continued to publish writings critical of the French government. As a result, he was exiled to Belgium and eventually went into exile with his family on the Isle of Guernsey in the English Channel.
One could argue that his life in exile was not merely a source of suffering but, rather, a blessing. Even after Louis Napoleon issued a pardon in 1859, Hugo chose to remain in exile. It was there that he published his masterpieces, including the poetry collection ‘Poèmes de l’Exil’ (1856), as well as the novels ‘Legends of the Centuries’ (1859) and ‘The Man Who Laughs’ (1869). ‘Les Misérables’ was also published in 1862 while he was in exile, 17 years after he first began writing it.
Political Life and Later Years
In 1870, when Louis-Napoléon’s Second Empire collapsed following the war with Prussia, Hugo arrived in Paris by train on the night of September 5 and received a grand welcome.
Although he was elected to the National Assembly, he was so disillusioned by the chaotic reality of politics that he resigned his seat shortly thereafter.
In 1876, he was elected to the Senate, but after suffering a cerebral hemorrhage in 1878, he ultimately retired from politics. On February 26, 1881, Hugo’s eightieth birthday was designated a temporary public holiday. A vast crowd gathered at his home to applaud him. Hugo had already written his “will” in 1881, four years before his death.
That will contained the following message:
God, the soul, and a sense of responsibility. These three ideas are enough. At least, they were enough for me. That is the true religion. I have lived by them, and I will die by them. Truth, light, justice, and conscience—that is God. I leave 40,000 francs to the poor. I hope it will be used to purchase materials for making coffins for the destitute. (……) My physical eyes will close, but the eyes of my soul will remain open forever.
Hugo’s Life Until the Very End
On May 18, 1885, Hugo took to his bed with pneumonia, and on the 22nd, he passed away in Paris. It is said that a storm accompanied by thunder and hail raged through Paris that night.
On June 1, his funeral was held as a state funeral. With a crowd of two million people following in his wake, his remains were interred in the Panthéon.
After reading ‘The Hunchback of Notre-Dame’, Quasimodo’s tragic love story may initially leave the strongest impression. However, upon a closer examination of the work, what lingers in the mind just as much as that love is the ugly and grotesque aspects of human nature—and the potential for beauty hidden within them. Because it presents imperfect and contradictory human beings rather than idealized heroes, the work compels us to reflect on the nature of humanity for much longer.
The characters in this novel are not extraordinary monsters but rather figures who reveal the various facets that exist within us as well. Therefore, the discomfort that ‘The Hunchback of Notre Dame’ evokes does not end as mere unease. It forces us to confront the “other self” within us, and the moment we acknowledge that aspect, we are led to envision even greater possibilities. Furthermore, through Quasimodo’s pure and innocent love, it makes us reflect on the fact that beauty can exist even within an ugly and miserable life.
Ultimately, this novel both shook me to my core and offered me comfort. Even in the moments when I felt discomfort while reading, I came to realize that perhaps this was part of the process of gaining a deeper understanding of humanity. Therefore, rather than reading ‘The Hunchback of Notre Dame’ merely as a tragic love story, I would like to read it while contemplating both the grotesque aspects of human nature and the beauty hidden within them.