How did Marcel Proust create a literature of memory and time through ‘In Search of Lost Time’?

In this blog post, we will explore Marcel Proust’s life and literary world, and summarize the overall narrative arc of ‘In Search of Lost Time’ as well as the significance of time and memory in ‘Swann’s Way’.

 

What kind of life did Marcel Proust lead?

Marcel Proust was born in 1871 in La Fontaine, a suburb of Paris. As a child, Marcel often went for walks with his nanny toward the Champs-Élysées, where he frequently met young girls and played hide-and-seek with them; these girls would later be depicted in his work as the “blooming maidens.”
During summer vacations, Marcel spent time in Illiers—his father’s hometown—with his younger brother Robert and his parents. Illiers is a rural village on the banks of the Loire River, southwest of the city of Chartres, famous for its cathedral. His aunt lived there; she appears in his works as “Aunt Léonie.”
In the novel, Illiers is described as “Combray.” Thanks to this work, Illiers—which gained fame as a result—is known today as “Illiers-Combray.” In the novel, roads extend in both directions from Combray: one leads to the cultured Jewish Swann family, or rather, to Méséglis; the other leads to the aristocratic Guermantes family. In other words, Combray can be seen as a crossroads with paths branching off in both directions. These two directions hold symbolic significance as two consistent strands in his work and play a crucial role in the growth and development of the protagonist, “I.”
What provided the decisive impetus for him to become a writer was his asthma. After contracting neurogenic asthma at the age of nine, it became a chronic condition that plagued him throughout his life, as he had been born with a frail constitution. Paradoxically, however, because of this chronic condition, he devoted himself to creative writing rather than adopting an extroverted and proactive outlook on life or career. Consequently, he focused on observation rather than participation, and on inner analysis rather than action; his affection for his mother and his poor health played the most significant roles in shaping his human condition and his entire life.
At the age of eleven, he enrolled at the Condorcet Middle and High School, where he immersed himself in reading numerous classical works. Among the French authors he enjoyed reading were the 17th-century writers de Sévigné, Saint-Simon, Hugo, Balzac, Baudelaire, and Stendhal; he also enjoyed reading foreign authors such as Eliot and Dostoevsky. Among contemporary French authors, he favored Anatole France and also read works by Le Maître, Loti, and Barrès.
For Marcel, writing was the process of reviving the reality of time and space—which would vanish in an instant—and breathing life into it; before he even realized it, he had become drawn into this work of recreation.
During his high school years, he discussed life and literature with outstanding friends such as Alévi, Greg, Fleur, and Dreyfus, and was already contributing works to literary journals.

 

How did Proust transform time and memory into literature?

Proust was greatly influenced by Bergson in many ways, though this influence stemmed more from Bergson’s theories on time and memory—as presented in ‘Essay on the Immediate Conditions of Consciousness’ and ‘Matter and Memory’—than from the vital dynamism of “creative evolution.” Nevertheless, he could not simply transpose Bergson’s theories directly into fiction. Proust believed that our sense of self dissolves as it becomes buried in time.
When we return to a place we loved in our childhood, we find that only the physical location remains. Fortunately, however, we have memory. And that memory is revived when, at a moment we believe to be coincidental, some unexpected event brings it to mind. Thus, while time is the agent of destruction, memory is the magician of preservation and sacrifice; the writer’s work of recreation can only take place when those memories make it possible to revive a past buried in time. We are well acquainted with such an example through the all-too-famous anecdote in which a madeleine cake brings back memories of the author’s childhood, which had otherwise been erased.
At one time, Proust contributed to literary journals such as ‘Le Festin’, ‘Le Revue Blanche’, and ‘Le Golu’. At the age of twenty-five, he published ‘Plaisirs et Jours’, though he had to cover the costs himself.
After that, he traveled to Venice and discovered the aesthete Ruskin, who had a profound influence on him, and devoured his works. He also translated ‘The Amiens Bible’, adding footnotes more detailed than the text itself and writing a preface.
Proust began writing his magnum opus, ‘In Search of Lost Time’, with all his might—first in his Osmann apartment in Paris, and then during the summers in Caubourg on the Normandy coast. The first volume, ‘Swann’s Way’, was completed. To publish this book, he approached ‘La Nouvelle Revue Française’, which was serving as the standard-bearer for the new literary movement. At the time, the most influential editor at ‘La Nouvelle Revue Française’ was André Gide, considered the godfather of the French literary world. He was renowned not only as a writer but also for his extraordinary discernment in discovering new talent. However, while reading a passage describing his Aunt Léonie’s hair, Gide came across a word he disliked, stopped reading, and threw the manuscript aside. Ultimately, he self-published the work through Grasset in 1913, and a favorable review of it appeared in the January issue of ‘La Nouvelle Revue Française’ the following year.
The year after the war ended, honor came his way. That year, he was awarded the Goncourt Prize, given to France’s leading novelists. However, rather than feeling elated by this recognition, he was overcome by anxiety that he might not be able to finish his epic novel. He sensed the shadow of death approaching. Ultimately, before his death, he was able to write “The End” on the work he had striven so desperately to complete. This was a victory over death for the author Proust, but above all, it was a triumph for 20th-century fiction and a stroke of immense good fortune.

 

What memories are revived in ‘Swann’s Way’?

Although the section introduced in this book is ‘Swann’s Way’, grasping the overall flow of ‘In Search of Lost Time’ will help in understanding the work, so I will summarize the plot of the entire series here.
The setting of the work is the narrator’s bedroom in Paris around 1910. Due to my habit of going to bed early, I wake up in the middle of the night and, along with the vague sensations I feel at that moment, recall my life in the various rooms and towns where I have lived. Memories of my childhood in Combray, my grandparents, my great-aunt, Aunt Léonie, and my anguish at not being able to have my mother all to myself because of the many visitors come to mind. However, even these memories are nothing more than fragmented snippets. One day, the taste of a piece of madeleine dipped in tea evokes the same sensation I felt back in my days in Combray, and in that instant, the entire past transcends time and is resurrected in my memory as its very essence. It is the magical power of unconscious recollection.
The narrative of his childhood in Combray unfolds a slice of rural bourgeois life between Aunt Léonie and her maid, Françoise. The rosy-cheeked woman I encountered at Great-Uncle Adolphe’s house appears as the prototype for Odette, who later became Swann’s wife. Influenced by my friend Bloch, “I” began to devour the works of Bergott, a literary giant of the time. I also met the musician Vinteuil and his daughter. Of the two directions taken on his regular walks—toward Méséglies (that is, toward Swann’s) and toward the Guermantes—it is on the Méséglies route that he sees Gilberte, the daughter of Swann and Odette, and also catches a fleeting glimpse of a man, Baron Charlus. During these walks, he feels desire for the first time toward an imaginary country girl and catches a glimpse of a secret scene involving Mademoiselle Vinteuil.
On the Germant side, as the carriage travels upstream through the town of Vibeau, the narrator’s passion for literature is depicted alongside his doubts about his own talent and his admiration for the Duchess of Germant, who is shrouded in legend; the three bell towers of Martinville and Vieux-Bic change subtly as the carriage passes by.
“I” hear from family members the story of Swann, a Jewish man and the son of a wealthy stockbroker, and Odette, a high-class courtesan. These recollections are narrated in an objective third-person style.
Through Odette, whom he met through a friend’s introduction, Swann begins to frequent the home of Madame Verdurin, a vulgar bourgeois salon. There, a short musical passage by Vinteuil that he hears brings Swann and Odette into a physical union. Swann’s passion for Odette and the process of erotic desire between a man and a woman are sharply depicted. Odette begins a relationship with the Count of Porcheville, and the Baron de Charley also enters the picture. Swann’s jealousy and anguish over this situation continue. Eventually, he is ostracized from the Verdurin salon. At a soirée, he hears the Banteuil motif again; just as his affection for the young Madame Cambremer begins to blossom, his love for Odette turns to indifference.
People and things derive their essence from their names. The names of the Gérmantes, Baron de Charlus, Madame Swann, and Gilbert Swann, among others, take on a life of their own. Consequently, the “I” dreams through these names. The poetic atmosphere of the Normandy coast at Balbec, Florence, and Venice—yet the trips never materialize due to illness. After growing indifferent to Odette, Swann marries her and they have a daughter named Gilberte. Gilberte becomes the narrator’s friend, and the narrator is tormented by feelings of affection for her.
One autumn day, while walking along an acacia-lined path, “I” feels a deep melancholy at the passage of time.

 

What will change in ‘Under the Shade of the Young Ladies’ Flowers’?

“I” goes to see ‘Phèdre’, performed by La Berma in Paris, and feels disillusioned. At the Swann House in Paris, “I” meets the great writer Bergott and is disillusioned by his appearance. Guided by Bloch, he visits a brothel and meets a Jewish prostitute named Rasel. A rift begins to form with Gilberte, and he feels the pain of their separation.
Two years later, he travels with his grandmother to Balbec on the Normandy coast. Along the way, the train stops at dawn, and there he sees a country girl selling milk, sensing the unique charm of the region. He is disappointed by the cathedral in Balbec, but three trees he sees on a walk suddenly give him the feeling that they are revealing something inexplicable. However, unable to grasp their meaning, he puts it off for later. He becomes friends with Robert Saint-Loup of the Germont family and is introduced to his maternal uncle, Baron de Charlus. He witnesses de Charlus’s eloquence and enigmatic behavior. He has dinner at the Bloch residence. He develops a romantic infatuation with a young woman from the seaside. She refuses his kiss on the hotel bed and leaves. And so, the summer in Balbec comes to an end.

 

How will the characters’ lives change in ‘Toward the Germonts’?

The narrator’s family moves into a section of the Germont mansion in Paris. I go to the opera house, see ‘La Berma’ again, and come to appreciate its true value. Seeing the beauty of the Duchess of Germant as she enters the theater, and watching her stroll once more, my heart pounds, and I rush to Saint-Loup, begging him to introduce me to his aunt. Returning to Paris, “I” go with Saint-Loup to meet his mistress, who turns out to be La Sel. Finally, I am introduced to the Duchess of Guermantes. We discuss the Dreyfus Affair. Baron de Charlus offers me a bizarre friendship. My grandmother’s frailty grows worse, and she suffers a cerebral hemorrhage.
I feel my affection for my grandmother deepening, but ultimately, I am present at her deathbed. Albertine visits, and he kisses her and goes for a walk with her. Charlus behaves strangely toward “I” when he visits him.

 

How do love and jealousy become entangled in ‘Sodom and Gomorrah’?

A reflection on sadism unfolds, centered on the homosexual scenes between Charlus and Jupien.
On the day of his second arrival in Balbec, a sudden flood of memories brings all his recollections of his grandmother back to life. As the resulting pain gradually subsides, Albertine visits and restores his peace of mind. Spending every day with Albertine, he begins to harbor suspicions about her behavior. Albertine’s homosexual tendencies are revealed. He feels affection for her, yet simultaneously wants to break off the relationship. Just as he is about to break off the relationship, the moment he hears her say she knows Mademoiselle Vinteuil’s girlfriend, he is overcome with jealousy and extracts a promise from his mother that she will allow him to marry Albertine. The narrator’s sole desire was to isolate her from the world. While his mother mourns his grandmother’s death, the narrator leaves Balbec, overcome by deep guilt and sorrow.

 

What kind of loss awaits in “The Captive Woman” and “The Fugitive Woman”?

Life unfolds as I bring Albertine to my home in Paris and care for her. On the surface, it seems like a peaceful existence, but beneath it all, a sense of ennui sets in—driven by the constant presence of others, intermittent jealousy, suspicions about Albertine, and the fear I feel toward the women of Paris, who remind me of Gomorrah—forcing me to abandon plans for a trip to Venice. Watching her play the piano, he tries to guess at the changes stirring within her heart but is frustrated by his inability to understand them; it is revealed for the first time, through the pet name she uses, that the narrator “I” is called “Marcel.” As spring arrives and his longing to travel to Venice grows intense, he waits for the moment to say goodbye to Albertine. One day, he learns from Françoise that she has left.
He feels intense anguish, desperate to bring Albertine back by any means necessary. He asks Saint-Loup to arrange it, but she does not return. He would rather she die than belong to another. One day, as he is feeling the same love-hate conflict that Swann had once experienced, he hears that she has fallen from a horse and died while out for a walk. Despair overwhelms him, and everything becomes a mere memory. Learning of her death makes her feel even more vivid to him. As memories of her resurface, he is consumed by the sorrow of having lost her. Meanwhile, the information he had previously requested about Albertine—specifically regarding her conduct—arrives, revealing her true nature. Jealousy and love once again overwhelm him. To stop thinking about her, he must forget everything—and to do so, he would have to die. He visits the Gérmantes and encounters Gilberte, who has changed beyond recognition. After Swann’s death, Odette married Porchville, and Gilberte has thus become Mademoiselle Porchville. He visits Venice and compares his impressions there with those he had in Combray. A telegram clearly arrives from the deceased Albertine, but the moment he receives it, he finds that he has already fully recovered from his anguish. All the sights of Venice seem fleeting, and he realizes the telegram must be a mistake. Meanwhile, Saint-Loup marries Gilberte. Time passes, and “I” stay at Gilberte’s house in Tansonville.

 

How does he discover literature in ‘Time Regained’?

Robert Saint-Loup undergoes a change in personality: he indulges in homosexual pleasures with a male model, while at the same time engaging with various women without any pleasure, thereby tormenting his wife, Gilberte. These symptoms are a form of complex hereditary disease found in old aristocratic lineages. On the last night before leaving Tangsongville, after reading Goncourt’s ‘Unpublished Diaries’, which Gilbert had lent him, he realizes he lacks literary talent. He finally gives up his plans to write and leaves for Paris to recuperate. In the meantime, World War I breaks out.
One evening in 1916, after returning to Paris, she goes out to meet Madame Verdurin, hoping to hear stories about the war. On her way, she runs into Charlus on the street. He had become an admirer of Germany. Charlus goes on and on in his praise of the invading German planes and their pilots. The hotel he entered for a drink was a place like Sodom, run by Jupien to provide Charles-Rue with a pleasure for his old age. There, he catches a glimpse of Baron Charles-Rue, chained up, bleeding as he is whipped by a young man, yet seemingly enjoying it. Robert Saint-Loup dies in the war.
On the train back to Paris from his second convalescent stay, as he gazes at the trees bathed in the setting sun, he is once again painfully reminded of his lack of talent for writing. Upon returning home, he finds an invitation from the Grand Duchess of Germinant. While driving there, he becomes lost in nostalgia as he passes through the streets where he used to play as a child. On the Champs-Élysées, he witnesses Jupien attending to the Count of Charlu, who has been reduced to a pitiful state by a stroke. As I stand at the entrance to the Grand Duchess’s mansion, pondering the depletion of my literary inspiration, I stumble over an uneven paving stone. At that moment, a sense of happiness washes over me, and the sensation of that uneven stone connects to the sensation of the baptismal font at St. Mark’s Basilica; then, all the other sensations associated with that memory bring Venice back to life. It was just like the memory of Combray that had been born in the madeleine. Why, then, did the images of Combray and Venice—even though they had no other specific focus at those respective moments—bring him a joy akin to a conviction that paid no heed to death? Determined to find the answer, he stepped inside the mansion. The revelation continues. The sound of a spoon touching a plate, the stiffness of a starched napkin, the sound of running water, a book seen again on the bookshelf—all of these, each based on the same impression, reveal the essence of existence within the timeless commonality of past and present. Only this miracle possesses the power to recover the true past—lost time. Translating these sensations, impressions, and images into forms that embody the same idea—in other words, transforming them into mental equivalents filled with anguish—is the only way to recover lost time and the only path to completing a work that has never been realized since the dawn of art.

 

About the author

Cam Tien

I love things that are gentle and cute. I love dogs, cats, and flowers because they make me happy. I also enjoy eating and traveling to discover new things. Besides that, I like to lie back, take in the scenery, and relax to enjoy life.